Homemade Protein vs. Whey Protein – Which One is Better?

Search “Homemade protein powder” on youtube. You’ll find that hundreds of videos claim that homemade protein powder is natural, cheaper, tasty, protein-rich, and much better than the widely popular “whey protein powder” supplement.  

How accurate is that claim? 

Let’s find out.    

The fitness industry in India has been multiplying for the last seven or eight years. However, the majority of the people are still not aware of the supplements and proper nutrition.

The lack of education and awareness leads to false/incorrect information on youtube or celebrity interviews. (Watch what Ayushman Khurana is saying about whey protein)

I find that these so-called “Fitness/Health YouTubers” are the main person behind spreading such misinformation/ in-complete knowledge for the sake of youtube views. 

These “Youtubers” claim that these kinds of homemade protein powder products are natural, cheaper, and even they guarantee you a better result with the homemade protein powder. 

A Health/Fitness Guide is No Joke. 

One misinformation or wrong critical advice can lead to health problems; that’s why it’s important to share the complete information. 

We will take few examples and compare the one serving of these “natural homemade protein powder.” 

Also, Read. Best Whey Protein Powder in India

Today, You’ll get the answer to the questions that include

  • Is homemade protein is cheaper than whey protein? 
  • Which protein can last for long?
  • Which one is calorie efficient? 
  • Which protein powder has more protein bioavailability(per serving)? 

Natural Homemade Protein vs Whey

Let’s take an example of a typical homemade protein powder.

Ingredients they use are

  • Almonds (100gm)
  • Walnuts (100gm)
  • Chia Seeds
  • Oats (50gm)
  • Milk Powder (50gm)
  • Peanuts (100gm)
  • Pumpkin Seeds (100gm)
  • Flex Seeds

A powder version of these ingredients will give you three to four servings. 

Now, let’s check the macros of this protein powder. 

Calorie you get

  • Almonds = 655kcal
  • Walnuts =  687cal
  • Chia Seeds = 31cal
  • Oats = 187cal
  • Milk Powder = 217cal
  • Peanuts = 567cal
  • Pumpkin Seeds = 446cal
  • Flex Seeds = 20cal

Total Calories = 2817

Total protein, carbs, and fat. 

  • Protein = 98gm
  • Carbohydrates = 244gm
  • Fat = 161gm

Macros Per serving:

  • Calories per serving = 2817/4

= 704.25 kcal

One serving of homemade protein has 704 calories. 

  • Protein (per serving) = 98/4 

= 24.5

  • Carbs = 244/ 4

= 61gm

  • Fat = 161/4

= 40.25gm

As you can see just one serving of the “natural homemade protein powder” has 2817 calories, 24 grams of protein, 61gm of carbs, and 40 grams of fat. 

  • Bioavailability of Protein= 24.5/126 *100

= 19.45 %

Let’s compare these macros per serving to a regular whey protein powder supplement. For the comparison, I am using Abborb Whey Isolate Protein (chocolate flavor).

 One serving(33grams) of abbzorb whey isolate provides

  • Calories = 124
  • Protein = 26gms
  • Carbs = 3.3gms
  • Fat = 0.6gm
  • Bioavailability of Protein = 26/33*100

= 78.79%

As you can see, Azzborb whey protein has more protein compared to the so-called natural protein powder. 

You get twenty-six grams of Protein at just 124 calories, where homemade Protein provides you 24 grams of Protein at 704 calories. 

Now let’s compare the respective cost of these two protein powders 

  • Homemade Protein Cost (per serving) 

= 330/4 

= 82.5 ₹ ($1.14)

  • Whey Protein Cost (per serving) 

  = 51.95 ₹ ($0.72)

You can check, neither the desi protein has more protein, nor this cost you cheaper. The “YouTubers” who spread this BS gained quite good views and money, manipulating and misleading the audience.   

They also claim that you can use homemade protein powder for weight gain or use protein powder as a mass gainer. Overeating/Overconsuming calories is not the way to gain good healthy muscles.  

Too many extra calories(excess calories) will end up gaining the fat on your body, not the lean muscles.

Homemade Protein vs Whey Protein Powder Comparison Table

Highlights(Per Serving)

Homemade Protein Powder

Whey Protein Powder

Calories 

700-750

120-140

Protein Bioavailability

20-24%

75-85%

Cost

80-90 Rupees

50-60 Rupees

Good for Fat Loss

NO

YES

Flavors

No Multiple Flavors

Multiple Flavors Available

Also, Read- High Protein Vegetarian Diet Without Any Protein Powder

Homemade Protein Powder vs Whey Protein: FAQs

Q. Is Homemade Protein Cheaper than Whey Protein? 

Ans. No. One serving of whey protein powder costs you rupees 50 to 60, where one serving of homemade protein costs 80 to 90 rupees. It’s not a cheap option for protein supplements. 

Q. Which protein can last for long?

Ans. Whey protein can last for more time. It can last for upto two years if kept in proper conditions. Whole homemade protein powder will be no use after one or two weeks. 

Supplements brands use different ingredients that increase the longevity of whey protein powder.

Q. Which Protein Powder is More Calorie Efficient?

Ans. Whey protein provides you more protein in a low calorie count. As we calculated earlier in the article, the protein bioavailability of protein is 75 to 80% in whey protein and it’s only 20% in homemade protein powder. 

Q. Can we use whey protein for weight loss? 

Ans. Yes, You can use whey protein for weight loss. There are plenty whey protein powder supplement that provides you 24 to 28 grams of protein at just 120 to 140 calories.

For weight loss, you have to follow a calorie deficit diet with the right amount of protein, carbs and essential fats. Proper nutrition, regular workout and good sleep/ recovery is the key to successful weight loss.   

Conclusion 

Don’t believe blindly in everything you learn on youtube. Health and fitness is a marathon, not a quick sprint. One has to stay consistent and dedicated to getting good results. 

People who look for “Fitness Hacks” on youtube don’t get good results, and they give up on their fat loss or muscle gain goals. 

My final advice would be to follow a well-balanced diet, workout routine, and a daily sleep of seven to eight hours. 

Don’t rely only on protein powders or any other supplements. Supplements mean supplement to something, and food/diet is the case here.  

Whey protein is a great protein supplement. 

You can use whey protein for fat loss or muscle gain. Whey protein provides you high quality of fast-absorbing protein at a limited calorie count. 

Whey protein has the most protein bioavailability among all other protein supplements. 

You can use whey protein in your breakfast, lunch, snack, pre-workout, or post-workout. The versatility and quality make whey protein the most sold protein supplement worldwide.

2 thoughts on “Homemade Protein vs. Whey Protein – Which One is Better?”

  1. I smell bias in your theory, it’s heavily one sided. Using a WPC 80 whey concentrate from a cow farm/cheese factory is more efficient than the company whey. 1: it’s safer because it’s a by product, no additives ,smells like goat or cow and no sweeteners.
    2: no need to worry about the ingredients used.
    How do I really know what azzborb put in their whey, maybe some tren, how can you tell. Someone uses a regular protein supplement for two months and becomes so huge and you think it’s normal. Bruh If you wanna make an ad do it openly stop bashing a homemade recipe.
    Supplement company whey poses a serious threat to your health than a homemade recipe which you know what’s inside 💠

    Reply
    • Wow. You know what, I am tired of one continuously repetitive lie that, whey is terrible for your health.

      Millions of athletes around the world use whey.

      I am not biased, nor does anyone sponsor me. I just presented you with a factual analysis of homemade protein powder (we find on youtube) vs. whey protein nutritional info.

      As far as protein powder ingredients; Companies can’t lie or hide ingredients from their customers, or they can never get approval from the food and drug department.

      I have been using whey protein for more than 4-5 years. I haven’t face any health issues.

      So, my friend, don’t believe in “Bro Science.”

      Please do your research based on facts and reports and believe in them.

      Reply

Leave a Comment